Open Adoption Pros and Cons in Pennsylvania

In an open adoption, you can maintain a relationship with your child and their adoptive family in a way that works for you.

Many expectant mothers want to stay connected, and open adoption makes that possible on your terms. But it’s also normal to have questions, doubts, or mixed feelings about what that contact might look like later on.

This guide will walk you through the open adoption pros and cons so you can make the decision that feels right for you. If you're ready to talk to someone now, call 1-800-ADOPTION or fill out our form to connect with an adoption specialist today.

Open Adoption: Pros and Cons

In an open adoption, you can have ongoing contact with the adoptive family before and after placement. This could include phone calls, texts, emails, video chats or in-person visits. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach — every open adoption is unique.

For many women, open adoption is a way to stay part of their child’s life while still choosing adoption. It gives you the chance to see how your child is doing, watch them grow up and build a relationship over time.

But how do you know if it’s the right path for you? Let’s look at both sides.

Pros of Open Adoption

There are many benefits of open adoption for both you and for your child:

Open adoption gives you the opportunity to stay in contact with your child as they grow. You can share your story and the reasons behind your decision, helping them understand that your choice came from a place of love.

Who seems to benefit from open adoptions the most? The answer is everyone involved. Adopted children tend to have higher self-esteem and fewer identity struggles. Adoptive parents feel more confident when they have a relationship with you. And you get to see your child thrive.

The openness of your adoption can be tailored to what you’re comfortable with. Whether it’s occasional updates or frequent visits, your adoption specialist will help you create a plan that fits your needs.

Cons of Open Adoption

While there are many positives, it’s also important to understand the potential challenges.

Can open adoption be emotionally hard later on? Yes, it can be. Staying in contact can stir up feelings of grief, especially in the early stages of healing.

There may be moments when your needs or the adoptive family’s needs shift. That’s okay. Your adoption specialist will be there to help you navigate those changes.

You might have family or friends who don’t “get” open adoption. That lack of understanding can be frustrating or isolating. That’s why it’s so important to have the right support.

What if I Don’t Want Contact After the Adoption?

Not every expectant mother wants an open adoption, and that’s completely okay. When thinking about open vs. closed adoption pros and cons, it’s important to know there’s a middle ground.

Semi-open adoption allows for limited contact, often through an adoption specialist. You might exchange letters and photos through your agency without direct interaction. This can offer peace of mind without the pressure of direct communication.

You have the right to set your contact preferences — and to change them later. If you choose American Adoptions of Pennsylvania, we’ll help you find a family that shares your preferences. And if those preferences change after placement, we’ll help you communicate that with the adoptive family.

How American Adoptions Supports Your Open Adoption

We’re here to help you move forward with confidence. When you work with American Adoptions of Pennsylvania, we provide:

Want to talk with someone today about your options? We’re ready to help. Fill out our form, call 1-800-ADOPTION or visit one of our offices to talk with an open adoption specialist.

Lewistown

3 W. Monument Square, Suite 210

Lewistown, PA 17044

1-800-ADOPTION

Philadelphia

1 International Plaza, Suite 550

Philadelphia, PA 19113

1-800-ADOPTION

Pittsburgh

301 Grant St., Suite 270

Pittsburgh, PA 15219

1-800-ADOPTION

Disclaimer
Information available through these links is the sole property of the companies and organizations listed therein. American Adoptions provides this information as a courtesy and is in no way responsible for its content or accuracy.

Request Free Information

View Waiting Families